Articles Tweens Teens & Twenties

Young Love: Healthy or Not?

By Alicia Wanek

…And then you’re on your very first date
And he’s got a car
And you’re feeling like flying
And your mama’s waiting up
And you’re thinking he’s the one
And you’re dancing around the room when the night ends
When the night ends

‘Cause when you’re fifteen,
Somebody tells you they love you
You’re gonna believe them
And when you’re fifteen

And your first kiss makes your head spin around

But in your life you’ll do things
Greater than dating the boy on the football team
But I didn’t know it at fifteen

When all you wanted
Was to be wanted
Wish you could go back
And tell yourself what you know now

Back then I swore I was gonna marry him someday…

– From “Fifteen” by Taylor Swift

Songs abound on the radio about young love and all its highs and lows. Memories of your first love stay with you. Sweet reflections of talking all night on the phone, your first kiss, and believing you would be together forever. You probably remember the breakup, too, because teenage romances rarely last long-term. When your own children start dating and experiencing those early relationships – along with the accompanying ups and downs – what role do you have? How much should you worry about them being “in love” as a teen or young adult? It is a delicate matter to be sure.

According to Dr. Dean Beckloff, licensed counselor and founder of the Beckloff Behavioral Health Center, the key is to listen. “Most people listen to respond rather than listening to understand,” Beckloff suggests. When it comes to talking to young people about their relationships, “you are there to hear and not judge,” he says. “Connect with what they may be thinking, believing, and what they may be feeling.” You can help them filter through their own thoughts as you listen. It is very natural too, he says, for teens to communicate more with one parent than the other.

And they called it puppy love
Oh I guess they’ll never know
How a young heart, how it really feels
And why I love her so

And they called it puppy love
Just because we’re seventeen
Tell them all
Oh please tell them it isn’t fair
To take away my only dream

– From “Puppy Love” by Paul Anka (re-recorded by Donny Osmond)

Research has shown that dating can build self-esteem and social skills as well as teach kids about healthy relationships, but how young is too young? Dr. Beckloff says that it is ultimately up to each family to decide, but young teenage romances are not necessarily bad. “The younger they are, the more controls they have,” Beckloff reminds parents. Younger teens can begin learning about relationships with more guidance from parents at home. 

Having “dating rules” from parents also gives the teenager some safeguards or excuses to use to get out of situations that they are not ready for or that make them uncomfortable.

Those early relationships usually involve a lot of time on the phone and seeing each other only at school or group events. Once they or their significant other turns sixteen and can drive, the game changes somewhat. There is a lot less supervision, so it is important for parents to ensure they have established their expectations. “By the time they get to college, they have more maturity, and you just hope they are making more mature decisions,” Dr. Beckloff says. That doesn’t mean, however, that they don’t still need you to be a listening ear.

Nothing really matters
I don’t really care
What nobody tell me
I’m gonna be here
It’s a matter of extreme importance
My first teenage love affair

– From “Teenage Love Affair” by Alicia Keys

What do you do when you have real concerns about the relationship? According to Dr. Beckloff, “Parents have to work hard at not panicking when they see negative or concerning behaviors or red flags,” though he recognizes that is hard to do. If at all possible, he suggests first waiting to see if “nature takes its course” because he warns parents they could push their child in the wrong direction. They do still need guidance from parents, but he points to the “I hate you/Don’t leave me” dilemma kids face. Sometimes they recognize they still need their parents but don’t necessarily want to hear their advice. “Parents ultimately do need to share concerns, understanding the teenager or young adult may reject them at first but may consider your words later and move in that direction,” Dr. Beckloff suggests.

Summer after high school when we first met…
Talk about our future like we had a clue
Never planned that one day I’d be losing you

In another life
I would be your girl
We’d keep all our promises
Be us against the world
In another life
I would make you stay
So I don’t have to say you were
The one that got away

– From “The One That Got Away” by Katy Perry

Rarely do teenage romances last. According to a study by Brandon Gaille Marketing, today only two percent of marriages are from a high school relationship. Dr. Beckloff says kids use words like “forever” even before they fully comprehend what that means. Thinking the relationship will last forever, they may have an especially difficult time when it comes to an end. “It can be devastating,” Beckloff says. “A breakup can create real grief whether they are the one who breaks up or is broken up with.” It is important that parents recognize that grief and not trivialize the child’s emotions.

In the midst of the pandemic, it may be even more difficult to see relationships end. Dr. Beckloff says, “We certainly have a lot of depression in our high school kids and college-age students these days. It seems it’s gotten harder to maintain all of our relationships, so breakups can be even harder if the teen or young adult is already somewhat depressed.” 

After a breakup, he suggests you should tell your kids, “I’m here, and we’re going to get through it.”  Once again, your role is to listen and not judge. It is important to let them know they are not alone. “Listen to music,” he says. “Why do you think there are so many songs about breakups?” 

That creates an entirely new playlist.

Related posts

DART Student Art Contest Celebrates Young Artists

goodlifefamilyadmin

That’s a Good Question! Podcast Episode 9: Am I a “Lawnmower Parent”?

goodlifefamilyadmin

The Problem with Teens No Longer Working Part-Time Jobs

goodlifefamilyadmin

Subscribe now and join the family!

Subscribe to the Good Life Family e-newsletters and automatically receive updates on new Good Life Family issues, articles, events, deals and coupons.

  • Stay up to date on the latest issues and articles
  • Get access to special deals and coupons
  • Automatically be entered in contests and giveaways
Close this popup